Recent Hugo debate aside (:-) I am again urging one and all who truly appreciate film to see this one. My prediction: this WILL earn Best Picture Oscar.
Based on the novel by Jonathan Safran Foer (thanks for telling me to read it, daughter!), a literary tour de force, the story is told by a 9 year old boy who has lost his father in 9.11. Keeping to my pledge of a general nod or not in this blog, I will simply say that this extraordinary story and directing of it serves as an anthem for every American post September 11.
I will think about this movie for a long, long time, just as the novel left its indelible mark on my heart.
I saw the previews on this new flick and decided not to venture into the tear-jerking world of a kid and widow who lose their family member on 9/11. The scenes I saw seemed on the level of afternoon soap-opera fare. But, wise colleague, I will consider altering my prejudicial view if you insist I see the the movie. Without divulging too many details, can you entice me to see it in spite of my reservations about pandering to films that do little more than try to make you sad?
ReplyDeleteMovie-going is very personal. I believe everyone is granted veto power for any reason. I, for one, can't see things like War Horse, because I suspect I'd cry throughout (even tho you cried out of the pain of a lame movie!). Genre I won't see? Horror. No need.
DeleteSo, David, don't go see Exceptionally.... But I will say, I didn't find this pandering. It dug deep into my sense of humanity and the value of relationships, especially as an American. Beautifully filmed, lovingly (and yes, with strong emotion) told with superb performances, its themes of redemption and healing will stay with me.
But no, I would never insist, friend.
Now I have to see it! I loved the book so much (a rare one to bring me to tears at its end) that I have reservations, but now that I know you approve of its adaptation I'll give it a whirl.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Valerie, for recognizing how personal movie going is. As you aptly noted, just as I don't care for what I can "tear-jerkers" (sorry, a demeaning term that describes a film you really enjoyed, and which Jenna intends to see), you don't care for horror films. No wonder you don't comment on my horror film posts! Yes indeed, that's the fun of our blog...different tastes and affinities. It is amazing, quand meme (ask Jenna to translate that one!), how much we do agree, Thanks for your sensitive and caring remarks, good buddy.
ReplyDeleteAfter reading your review and my favorite cousin's replies, I feel compelled to see it! We have another distant cousin who was unfortunately in the 2nd building of the World Trade Center >100th floor on 9-11. He at 40 left behind a wife and 2 boys; 1 and 3 yrs. old. I must go see this! Keep your exciting and interesting reviews coming! Georgia
ReplyDeleteGeorgia, I am struck by your draw to see this. To be sure, your own personal family connection to this subject will add such an emotional poignancy to this film.
ReplyDeleteBy the way, I hope you will weigh in here after you have watched it.
Peace.
Hope you enjoy it, Georgia. I think you and Valerie may well have similar film interests. Please write up a storm on our blog! We need your intelligence and wit!
ReplyDelete